Skip to main content
Deliberative Friction: Participant Perspectives on Managing Disagreement in a National Citizens’ Panel

Abstract

This is an accepted article with a DOI pre-assigned that is not yet published.

Deliberative mini-publics (DMPs) are typically justified by two aims: producing policy-relevant recommendations and enabling inclusive, reflective deliberation. While these goals may reinforce each other, design choices that prioritize outputs can suppress the contestation that underpins deliberative legitimacy. This paper examines how members of Sweden’s first national deliberative mini-public – the Food Agency’s Citizen Panel on Sustainable Diets – experienced disagreement within deliberation. Drawing on semi-structured interviews with 15 panel members and participant observation, we analyze how participants navigated what we call deliberative friction: moments when disagreement interrupts deliberative flow and makes differences visible. Although participants valued both policy impact and inclusive exchange, many experienced the process as insufficiently frictional. Strong output orientation, time pressure, voting procedures, vague recommendation framing, digital sessions, fatigue, consensus norms, and inequalities in rhetorical authority often led members to self-censor disagreement or defer contestation to voting. We conclude with practical suggestions for how DMPs can be designed to support deliberative friction without undermining collective progress.

Keywords

Agonistic deliberation, Culture, Deliberative Friction, Sweden, Instrumental value, Inherent value, Interview study, Phenomenology, Assembly design

Funding

Name
IKEA Foundation
FundRef ID
https://doi.org/10.13039/501100022723
Funding Statement

Funded Philip Bärring, Tim M. Daw, and Therese Lindahl

Name
Stiftelsen för Miljöstrategisk Forskning
FundRef ID
https://doi.org/10.13039/100007633
Funding ID
DIA 2018/24 #8
Funding Statement

Funded Therese Lindahl

Name
Svenska Forskningsrådet Formas
FundRef ID
https://doi.org/10.13039/501100001862
Funding ID
Grant 2023-00767
Funding Statement

Funded Philip Bärring and Tim M. Daw.

Name
Svenska Forskningsrådet Formas
FundRef ID
https://doi.org/10.13039/501100001862
Funding ID
registration number 2023-00767
Funding Statement

Funded Philip Bärring

Name
Svenska Forskningsrådet Formas
FundRef ID
https://doi.org/10.13039/501100001862
Funding ID
Grant 2020-00175
Funding Statement

Funded Therese Lindahl

Share

Authors

Issue

  • This article is not a part of any issues.

Publication details

Licence

Creative Commons Attribution 4.0

Identifiers

Peer Review

This article has been peer reviewed.

Competing Interests

No competing interests to report from any of the authors