Skip to main content
Closely Divided, Not Deeply Divided: Identifying the Structures of Polarized Discourse in the United States

Abstract

This is an accepted article with a DOI pre-assigned that is not yet published.

Political polarization in the United States is widely understood to be intensifying. Beyond disagreement on policy positions, polarization increasingly manifests as an inability to recognize areas of shared concern or common ground in how political issues are framed. Yet, as Habermas reminds us, democratic consensus does not necessarily require agreement on specific issues; rather, it depends on the existence of communicative conditions that allow democratic deliberation to take place. Reframing polarization as a discursive problem rooted in how political issues are narrated, structured, and juxtaposed opens new possibilities for understanding how polarized communication might be repaired. This paper adopts such a discursive perspective by examining political discourse on Reddit (N=2000 posts), a platform often characterized as highly polarized. Through a mixed-method analysis of partisan subreddits, and the conceptual tool of narrative juxtaposition, the study demonstrates that despite ideological division, the structural features of communication and key narrative frames remain strikingly similar across partisan spaces. These shared discursive structures suggest that opportunities exist for reframing political issues in ways that reduce antagonism, appeal to moderate voters, and invite us to think about approaching polarized discourse in relational rather than binary terms. 

Keywords

Polarization, US, Disourse, Republican, Democrat, Mixed-Methods, Reddit

Share

Author

Issue

  • This article is not a part of any issues.

Publication details

Licence

Creative Commons Attribution 4.0

Identifiers

Peer Review

This article has been peer reviewed.

Competing Interests

The author has no competing interests to declare