Abstract
This is an accepted article with a DOI pre-assigned that is not yet published.
Recent advances in text analysis have renewed scholarly interest in measuring the quality of legislative debate, yet existing metrics remain grounded in deliberative democratic theory. The Discourse Quality Index (DQI), the dominant tool in this literature, evaluates discourse against ideals of rationality, inclusion, and common-good orientation. This article advances deliberative scholarship by showing that applying these standards to adversarial Westminster parliaments may risk systematic mismeasurement. As a concept-building exercise, it develops the Parliamentary Discourse Quality Index (pDQI), a framework tailored to the normative purposes of parliamentary democracy. Rather than assessing how closely debate approximates deliberation, the pDQI evaluates how effectively parliamentary speech performs core constitutional functions, including scrutiny, representation, legitimation, and public education. We delineate the scope conditions of deliberative evaluation while offering a complementary framework for by-design adversarial legislatures.
Keywords
Discourse quality index, parliament, legislative debate, political debate, discourse quality index, parliamentary debate